Bayview Pizza Menu (Updated 2026)

Introducing Bayview Pizza, a hidden gem nestled at 800 Hwy 551 in M'Chigeeng, Ontario, where culinary craftsmanship meets community spirit. Renowned for its diverse selection, the menu showcases an array of flavors with tantalizing wet sauces like Mesquite BBQ and Applewood Bourbon, alongside robust dry rubs including Maple Bacon and Smoke Applewood. Pizzas like the Meat Lovers and original Hawaiian are crafted with love, ensuring every bite is a delightful experience.

Customer reviews say it all—people rave about the generous portions and remarkable taste, especially the sweet yet savory sauce. Many appreciate the accommodating staff, eager to meet dietary restrictions. Whether you're diving into a fiery Buffalo pizza or enjoying a classic Pepperoni with ample toppings, Bayview Pizza stands out as a must-visit dining destination. With warm service, great parking, and delightful late-night hours, this pizzeria is perfect for any pizza enthusiast on Manitoulin Island.

The menu features a focus on classic comfort foods, with pizza, wraps, and fried chicken as primary categories. Pricing ranges mainly between CA$10 and CA$20, positioning most items as moderately priced options. Wraps and regular fries offer budget-friendly choices, while larger portions like the 8-piece fried chicken and family-sized poutine provide higher value for groups or bigger appetites. The inclusion of substantial items such as meatball subs and poutines suggests versatility for both lunch and dinner occasions.